Red Team Proposal Review

Red team proposal review by a mock evaluation board: we score your draft against the evaluation criteria and log strengths, weaknesses and deficiencies.

Skip to content

Red Team Proposal Review

Red team proposal review by a mock evaluation board: we score your draft against the evaluation criteria and log strengths, weaknesses and deficiencies.

What a red team review scores

A red team review is a simulated evaluation. Reviewers who did not write the draft read it as the source selection board will: against the evaluation criteria, factor by factor, with no knowledge of what the authors meant to say. What they cannot find, the real evaluators will not find either.

Our red team works as a mock evaluation board. It scores the near-final draft against the criteria in the solicitation and logs strengths, weaknesses and deficiencies for each factor. The result is a list of specific changes, ranked by what they are worth in score, rather than a page of general comments.

Pink, Red and Gold: which review when

Color team reviews are named for the stage of the draft they check. A Pink team reads the early draft or the storyboard and asks whether the structure and the win themes will work before the full text is written. A Red team reads the near-final draft as the evaluators will and scores it. A Gold team is the last read before release, by the people who sign off on the response.

Pink and Red team reviews are part of every Shaavir tier. They sit inside the three structured passes every proposal goes through: L1, L2 and your own review.

L1 compliance audit and L2 evaluator read

Our reviews run at two levels before the draft reaches you. L1 is a compliance and completeness audit: every requirement in the matrix is checked against the section that should answer it, along with page limits, format rules and required forms. L2 is a scoring-focused evaluator read: the draft is read for strengths and weaknesses against the criteria, the way a source selection board reads it.

Splitting the two keeps each pass honest. A compliance check that also tries to judge persuasion tends to skip rows, and a persuasion read that stops for every format rule tends to lose the argument. After L1 and L2, your own review is the third pass.

What you get back: a findings log tracked to resolution

Every finding is logged with the section it concerns, what is wrong and what would fix it. Each one gets an owner and is tracked to resolution in Orbit before the response ships. The log stays with the pursuit, so you can see what was found, who fixed it and when it was closed.

Because the review works from the same compliance matrix the writers used, each finding points to a specific requirement and a specific section. That makes it quick to act on, even late in the schedule.

Reviews inside the Assist tier

Assist is built for teams that have a writer and need surge help: you run the pursuit and we plug in with the compliance matrix, outline and section review, Pink and Red team reviews and graphics, for one or two proposals or selected phases, with a proposal writer and a graphic designer.

Manage & Write and End to End go further. A proposal manager orchestrates the L1 and L2 reviews and coordinates your review, and the findings are closed inside the same sprint plan as the drafting. Review cycles can also be bought à la carte. Contact us for pricing.

Frequently asked questions

Related services

Related services

Guides

Contact Shaavir · View services · Read the blog · Careers · Case studies · Privacy policy · Terms