Tradeoff Source Selection: How Price Loses

A tradeoff source selection pays a premium only for a benefit the source selection authority can name. Learn what earns it and what cancels out. A tradeoff lets the government pay more for the better proposal, but only where an official can name the benefit and write it down. This post covers what earns a premium, what cancels out, and what the customer can strip. A tradeoff source selection lets the government pay more for the better proposal. It does not let the government pay more for a better proposal in the abstract. FAR 15.101-1(c) sets one test: "The perceived benefits of the higher priced proposal shall merit the additional cost." Somebody has to name that benefit, set it against your price premium, and write the sentence down. So the bidder's question is narrow. Which specific advantage in your proposal can a government official describe, in prose, against the proposal sitting next to yours? That advantage is what buys the premium. The rest of your volume is reading time. What Tradeoff Source Selection Permits FAR 15.302 states the objective plainly. Source selection exists "to select the proposal that represents the best value." A tradeoff is one route to that answer. FAR 15.101-1(a) (https://www.acquisition.gov/far/subpart-15.1) calls a tradeoff appropriate where the government may consider award to "other than the lowest priced offeror." The same sentence adds "or other than the highest technically rated offeror." Read the second half of that sentence. The same process that can pay a premium can also refuse one. A tradeoff lets the contracting officer buy the cheaper proposal and accept its weaknesses. The Department of Defense Source Selection Procedures of 20 August 2022 name what a premium buys. The process lets the government accept a higher priced or lower rated proposal for four named reasons. Those are performance "in excess of the threshold and up to the objective requirements, lower risk, or innovative and technologically superior solutions." Those four things are the whole menu. Performance above the floor, lower risk, innovation, technical superiority. An advantage that fits none of them has no slot in the decision. LPTA works the other way, and our earlier post on LPTA against best value (/blog/lpta-vs-best-value) covers what that does to your prose. The federal source selection process guide (/blog/federal-source-selection-process) walks the whole path from evaluation board to award. The Comparison Happens Upstairs Here is the part most capture plans miss. The evaluators who read your technical volume usually never compare it to anyone else's. The Army Source Selection Supplement prints the rule as a reminder, citing DoD Source Selection Procedures paragraph 1.4.4.4.3. The evaluation board "shall not perform comparative analysis of proposals or make source selection recommendations unless re

Skip to content

Tradeoff Source Selection: How Price Loses

By

A tradeoff source selection pays a premium only for a benefit the source selection authority can name. Learn what earns it and what cancels out. A tradeoff lets the government pay more for the better proposal, but only where an official can name the benefit and write it down. This post covers what earns a premium, what cancels out, and what the customer can strip. A tradeoff source selection lets the government pay more for the better proposal. It does not let the government pay more for a better proposal in the abstract. FAR 15.101-1(c) sets one test: "The perceived benefits of the higher priced proposal shall merit the additional cost." Somebody has to name that benefit, set it against your price premium, and write the sentence down. So the bidder's question is narrow. Which specific advantage in your proposal can a government official describe, in prose, against the proposal sitting next to yours? That advantage is what buys the premium. The rest of your volume is reading time. What Tradeoff Source Selection Permits FAR 15.302 states the objective plainly. Source selection exists "to select the proposal that represents the best value." A tradeoff is one route to that answer. FAR 15.101-1(a) (https://www.acquisition.gov/far/subpart-15.1) calls a tradeoff appropriate where the government may consider award to "other than the lowest priced offeror." The same sentence adds "or other than the highest technically rated offeror." Read the second half of that sentence. The same process that can pay a premium can also refuse one. A tradeoff lets the contracting officer buy the cheaper proposal and accept its weaknesses. The Department of Defense Source Selection Procedures of 20 August 2022 name what a premium buys. The process lets the government accept a higher priced or lower rated proposal for four named reasons. Those are performance "in excess of the threshold and up to the objective requirements, lower risk, or innovative and technologically superior solutions." Those four things are the whole menu. Performance above the floor, lower risk, innovation, technical superiority. An advantage that fits none of them has no slot in the decision. LPTA works the other way, and our earlier post on LPTA against best value (/blog/lpta-vs-best-value) covers what that does to your prose. The federal source selection process guide (/blog/federal-source-selection-process) walks the whole path from evaluation board to award. The Comparison Happens Upstairs Here is the part most capture plans miss. The evaluators who read your technical volume usually never compare it to anyone else's. The Army Source Selection Supplement prints the rule as a reminder, citing DoD Source Selection Procedures paragraph 1.4.4.4.3. The evaluation board "shall not perform comparative analysis of proposals or make source selection recommendations unless re

A tradeoff lets the government pay more for the better proposal, but only where an official can name the benefit and write it down. This post covers what earns a premium, what cancels out, and what the customer can strip.

A tradeoff source selection lets the government pay more for the better proposal. It does not let the government pay more for a better proposal in the abstract. FAR 15.101-1(c) sets one test: "The perceived benefits of the higher priced proposal shall merit the additional cost." Somebody has to name that benefit, set it against your price premium, and write the sentence down. So the bidder's question is narrow. Which specific advantage in your proposal can a government official describe, in prose, against the proposal sitting next to yours? That advantage is what buys the premium. The rest of your volume is reading time. What Tradeoff Source Selection Permits FAR 15.302 states the objective plainly. Source selection exists "to select the proposal that represents the best value." A tradeoff is one route to that answer. FAR 15.101-1(a) (https://www.acquisition.gov/far/subpart-15.1) calls a tradeoff appropriate where the government may consider award to "other than the lowest priced offeror." The same sentence adds "or other than the highest technically rated offeror." Read the second half of that sentence. The same process that can pay a premium can also refuse one. A tradeoff lets the contracting officer buy the cheaper proposal and accept its weaknesses. The Department of Defense Source Selection Procedures of 20 August 2022 name what a premium buys. The process lets the government accept a higher priced or lower rated proposal for four named reasons. Those are performance "in excess of the threshold and up to the objective requirements, lower risk, or innovative and technologically superior solutions." Those four things are the whole menu. Performance above the floor, lower risk, innovation, technical superiority. An advantage that fits none of them has no slot in the decision. LPTA works the other way, and our earlier post on LPTA against best value (/blog/lpta-vs-best-value) covers what that does to your prose. The federal source selection process guide (/blog/federal-source-selection-process) walks the whole path from evaluation board to award. The Comparison Happens Upstairs Here is the part most capture plans miss. The evaluators who read your technical volume usually never compare it to anyone else's. The Army Source Selection Supplement prints the rule as a reminder, citing DoD Source Selection Procedures paragraph 1.4.4.4.3. The evaluation board "shall not perform comparative analysis of proposals or make source selection recommendations unless re

Contact Shaavir · View services · Read the blog · Careers · Case studies · Privacy policy · Terms